Perimenopause is that delightful phase leading up to menopause when your hormones start playing a chaotic game of musical chairs. One day, you feel fine; the next, you’re sweating through your sheets at 3 a.m., snapping at your partner over absolutely nothing, and wondering if you’ve lost your mind. Welcome to the hormonal rollercoaster, no one warned you about!
For decades, women have been handed birth control pills as a one-size-fits-all solution to manage perimenopause symptoms. But here’s the deal—birth control pills are often a lousy fix for what’s really going on in your body. Let’s break it down.
Birth Control Pills vs. Perimenopause: The Mismatch
- Birth Control Pills Are Designed to Prevent Pregnancy—Not to Balance Menopause Hormones
Birth control pills work by shutting down ovulation. They pump a steady stream of synthetic estrogen and progestin into your system, overriding your natural hormonal fluctuations. Sounds great in theory, right? Not so fast! Perimenopause isn’t about stopping ovulation—it’s about declining ovarian function and the wild swings of estrogen and progesterone that come with it.
Translation: The hormones in birth control pills don’t replace what your body is missing during perimenopause. Instead, they suppress your natural hormone production, potentially worsening things in the long run.
- Too Much of the Wrong Estrogen
Most birth control pills contain ethinyl estradiol, a synthetic estrogen that is WAY more potent than the bioidentical estradiol your body naturally produces. This can cause some perimenopausal women to experience side effects like headaches, bloating, nausea, and even worsening mood swings. So, if you’re already feeling like an emotional wreck, adding extra synthetic hormones to the mix might not be the magic fix you were hoping for.
- They Don’t Address the Real Problem: Progesterone Deficiency
A major driver of perimenopause symptoms is low progesterone. In your reproductive years, progesterone keeps estrogen in check. But during perimenopause, your progesterone levels take a nosedive, leaving estrogen unchecked and leading to symptoms like heavy periods, anxiety, and sleep disturbances.
Birth control pills contain progestins, which are NOT the same as the natural progesterone your body produces. Progestins can actually worsen mood-related symptoms, increase breast tenderness, and even contribute to weight gain. If you’re struggling with perimenopausal anxiety and insomnia, synthetic progestins aren’t going to do you any favors.
- They Can Mask Perimenopause Rather Than Treat It
Birth control pills can regulate your cycle, making it seem like everything is under control. But that’s just it—it’s an illusion. Because they prevent ovulation and induce artificial withdrawal bleeds, they don’t actually help your body transition through perimenopause in a healthy way.
So, you might be thinking, “Well, if birth control pills mask my symptoms, isn’t that a good thing?” Not really. Because when you stop taking them (which you eventually will), you may experience a sudden and dramatic hormone crash, leaving you feeling like you’ve been hit by a hormonal freight train.
- They Can Increase Your Risk of Blood Clots and Stroke
Women in their 40s already have a slightly higher risk of cardiovascular issues, and birth control pills can further increase the risk of blood clots, stroke, and high blood pressure—especially if you smoke or have other risk factors. If you’re dealing with perimenopausal migraines (which are common), birth control pills can make them worse and put you at an even higher risk for stroke. Yikes!
So, What’s a Perimenopausal Gal to Do?
If birth control pills aren’t the best answer, what is? The good news is, you have options!
- Consider Bioidentical Hormone Therapy (HT)
Unlike birth control pills, bioidentical hormone therapy (HT) provides hormones that are molecularly identical to what your body naturally produces. This means your body actually recognizes and uses them properly! HT can help smooth out the crazy ups and downs of perimenopause without shutting down your natural hormone production.
If you’re perimenopausal, transdermal estradiol (such as a patch, gel, or spray) can be an effective way to stabilize your estrogen levels. However, if you still have a uterus, you can still get pregnant until you have gone a full 12 consecutive months without a period and officially reached menopause. To protect against both pregnancy and the effects of unopposed estrogen on the uterus, a progesterone-releasing IUD (such as the Mirena) can be a great option. It provides localized progesterone to help prevent heavy bleeding while also acting as birth control.
- Support Your Adrenals
Your adrenal glands help produce hormones like cortisol and DHEA, which can compensate for some of the hormone loss that happens during perimenopause. Chronic stress depletes these hormones, so managing stress through meditation, yoga, or even just saying no to things that drain you can make a huge difference.
- Optimize Your Nutrition
Certain foods can help support hormone balance. Focus on:
- Protein (for blood sugar stability)
- Healthy fats (for hormone production)
- Cruciferous vegetables (for estrogen metabolism)
- Magnesium and B vitamins (for stress support)
- Prioritize Sleep
Perimenopause can wreak havoc on sleep, but making sleep a priority is crucial for hormone balance. Try creating a wind-down routine, avoiding screens before bed, and keeping your bedroom cool and dark.
- Move Your Body—but Don’t Overdo It
Exercise is fantastic for hormone balance, but high-intensity workouts can sometimes stress the body and make symptoms worse. Strength training, walking, and yoga can be more beneficial than endless cardio sessions.
- Libido: Another Reason to Ditch the Pill
Many women notice a significant drop in libido while on birth control pills. That’s because synthetic progestins can lower testosterone levels, which are crucial for sex drive. Bioidentical transdermal estradiol, on the other hand, does not have this libido-zapping effect. In fact, when properly balanced with progesterone and testosterone (if needed), bioidentical HT can help restore a healthy sex drive.
The Bottom Line
Birth control pills have their place—they’re great for preventing pregnancy. But if you’re struggling with perimenopause symptoms, they’re often not the right tool for the job. Instead of masking symptoms and throwing synthetic hormones into the mix, it’s time to support your body with approaches that truly help you transition into menopause feeling your best.
If you’re feeling lost in the perimenopause maze, don’t suffer in silence—reach out! There are real solutions that actually work.
Stay fearless, fabulous, and informed!
Sign up for Fearless VaginaTM A Crash Course in Mastering Menopause
Check out my fabulous Fearless VaginaTM Store
If you want to educate your employees, colleagues, or friends about menopause, look no further! Book Ellen for your next event.
Sign up for Menopause Mondays® Blogs
Be sure to follow me on Instagram, Facebook, and LinkedIn.
*EllenDolgen.com does not recommend, endorse, or make any representation about any tests, studies, practices, procedures, treatments, services, opinions, healthcare providers, physicians, or medical institutions that may be mentioned or referenced. The information, including opinions and recommendations, contained on this website is intended for informational and educational purposes only. Such information is not intended to be a substitute for the advice of an appropriately qualified and licensed physician or other healthcare provider.
