Breast Cancer and Menopause - Ellen Dolgen

Breast Cancer and Menopause

Think back to your PRE-menopause days. If someone told you they could trigger menopause for you, you’d hardly have jumped at the chance, right? But that’s exactly what many cancer survivors younger than 50 – or even younger than 40 – experience.

Each year in the U.S., almost 50,000 women younger than 50 are diagnosed with invasive breast cancer. Nearly 10,000 of them are younger than 40. During chemotherapy, women may have irregular menstrual cycles, amenorrhea (disappearance of menstrual periods), menopausal symptoms or be thrown into actual menopause. Menopause may be immediate or delayed, permanent or temporary when triggered by chemotherapy.

I reached out to the Yale Cancer Center and spoke to Dr. Erin W. Hofstatter, Assistant Professor of Medicine (Medical Oncology); Co-Director, Genetic Counseling Program, and Dr. Elena Ratner, Assistant Professor of Obstetrics, Gynecology, and Reproductive Sciences, to shed some light on issues of concern to my readers. They graciously provided me with philanthropy of their knowledge!

Tomosynthesis Mammography

Dr. Hofstatter flatly responded, “I am a huge fan.” More and more data shows that this 3-D mammography cuts false-positives and call-back rates, and is picking up a few extra cancers per 1,000 women screened. It is a small amount of extra radiation compared to the usual 2-D mammogram, but is well worth it since it reduces call-backs and need for diagnostic mammograms (which are a lot more radiation than a screening 2-D mammo).

Genetic Testing For BRCA1 and BRCA2

Dr. Hofstatter noted that about 5 percent of breast cancer patients test positive for the BRCA1 and BRCA2 genes associated with the disease. However, the likelihood of testing positive for a woman with breast cancer depends on how old she is, if she is of Ashkenazi Jewish heritage, and what type of breast cancer she has. All these women have a slightly higher chance of testing positive. Here are some stats on the chances of women with breast cancer testing positive:

  • Non-Ashkenazi Jewish woman with breast cancer at any age: 1 in 50 -2 percent
  • Non-Ashkenazi Jewish woman with breast cancer <age 40: Less than 10 percent
  • Ashkenazi Jewish woman with breast cancer at any age: 10 percent
  • Ashkenazi Jewish woman with breast cancer <40: 30-35 percent
  • Woman of any descent any age with triple negative breast cancer: roughly 10-20 percent

I asked Dr. Ratner what her thoughts were on the new research on Ashkenazi Jews and BRCA1 and BRCA2. The study recommends routine screening for the BRCA1 and BRCA2 genes for all women of Ashkenazi Jewish descent – even without a family history. Her research actually deals in gene mutation. She said she thinks it is very reasonable for women of Ashkenazi descent to be tested.  Knowing your genetic mutations and what predisposes us to cancers is beneficial so that we can actually be proactive about it.

Dr. Ratner explained that the standard care options for women who carry the gene vary depending on the medical history of each patient. However, it is recommended that you add an MRI and sonogram – alternating at six-month intervals for breast cancer screening. For ovarian cancer screening, usually it is a pelvic (vaginal) ultrasound done every 12 months and a blood test CA-125 done every 6-12 months.

Breast Cancer Treatment Options

Research is also continuing on surgical treatment of breast cancer. Dr. Hofstatter shared her analysis of a recent JAMA study on the survival benefit of a double mastectomy in treating unilateral breast cancer. “Many women diagnosed with a breast cancer believe that getting a bilateral mastectomy will help them to improve their chances of curing the cancer and will make them live longer,” she said.

“The truth is, once the cancer has developed, the long-term risk of the cancer to someone’s health is the same no matter what surgery they choose. In other words, the chances that their cancer will recur at a later time are the same regardless of the surgery they choose.  If a woman chooses bilateral mastectomy, she should understand that the purpose of that type of surgery is to prevent a second, new breast cancer in the future. For most women, the chances of developing another new breast cancer is .5 – 1 percent per year. I completely understand why a woman might want to be aggressive about her surgical options, and I always think it should be a patient’s choice. However, I fear women are ‘going under the knife’ without truly understanding the risks and benefits of the procedure. If anything, this JAMA study supports the idea that breast conservation is a safe option both in the short term and long term for most women.”

Breast Cancer After-Care Protocol

I was wondering what the “best practice” is now for breast cancer survivors and the length of time they will need to take drugs like Aromasin/Exemestane. Many women email me that they were originally told five years; however, it seems that the protocol is changing to 10 years.

According to Dr. Hofstatter, just how long women must be on these drugs is up for debate. She said she feels that the new standard will likely be 10 years. For pre-menopausal women, she said, 10 years of Tamoxifen has been proven to be better than five years. No data yet definitively says that 10 years of an aromatase inhibitor is best, but the guidelines are saying to “consider it” in all patients who have completed five years.

“The BCI Index is designed to help doctors and patients decide the length of treatment. This test takes the original tissue from cancer and sends it to the company, which studies gene expression of several different genes in the particular woman’s tumor. Based on these results, a statistical report is produced that estimates the possible benefit from extended therapy.”

Dr. Hofstatter predicts that the clinical use of the BCI will increase over the coming years, and will likely become a new standard.

Treatment for DCIS

I asked Dr. Hofstatter what the recommended protocols are for women with ductal carcinoma in situ (DCIS). She said DCIS is still officially considered a breast cancer but is non-invasive. This means, by definition, it cannot spread outside the breast, and therefore cannot be life-threatening. Women are typically treated for DCIS-type cancer with radiation and surgery, and oftentimes anti-hormonal agents that carry side effects. But some people are suggesting that this is “overkill” and that the treatment is worse than the disease. Some suggest that we should leave DCIS alone, not call it cancer, and instead consider it a “high-risk lesion.” This debate will go on for years.

What we do know, she said, is that, while many DCIS lesions lie dormant and harmless for many, many years, there are others that do invade and become dangerous. We do not fully understand which DCIS lesions are which, so it becomes hard to pick and choose which patients need everything and which don’t. The bottom line is that women should talk with their doctors about their particular DCIS lesion, and decide which therapies are best for them. Sometimes, surgery with either radiation or anti-hormone pills is acceptable.

Treatment of Menopausal Symptoms

At Yale, Dr. Hofstatter is studying the use of Remifemin (estrogen-free black cohosh) in early-stage breast cancer, specifically DCIS, to see if a few weeks of Remifemin taken before surgery can reduce cell proliferation in areas of DCIS.

For breast cancer survivor Vicky, Remifemin was just what the doctor ordered. “I am 48 now and was treated at 35 for stage 1b breast cancer with surgery, chemo, radiation, and Tamoxifen,” she said. “Hot flashes started full on for me … and I immediately went on Remifemin…. The hot flashes are about 98 percent gone.”

Osteoporosis Prevention

And, while estrogen protects bone health, for breast cancer patients Dr. Ratner prescribes two 600mg doses of calcium twice a day with vitamin D, plus cardio and low weight-bearing exercise.

Fertility Preservation

Many of these young breast cancer patients also hope to start a family, but toxic treatments such as chemo can adversely affect their fertility. Dr. Ratner stresses the importance for women and their providers to discuss fertility prior to their treatment. Some chemotherapy will not affect fertility in the long fun but others may.

I am so grateful for the generosity of these wonderful experts at the Yale Cancer Center. Knowledge is power!

My motto: Suffering in silence is OUT! Reaching out is IN! 

Download my free eBook: MENOPAUSE MONDAYS  the Girlfriend’s Guide to Surviving and Thriving During Perimenopause and Menopause.

Be sure to sign up for my fun YouTube Videos!



14 thoughts on “Breast Cancer and Menopause”

  1. I love how integrative medicine is getting and how physicians are prescribing activity and vitamins in addition to Rx drugs. This is another post chock-full of good info, Ellen. Thanks.

    1. I agree, Carol. Sometimes it takes a little time for traditional medicine to be open to the more integrative approaches. But, I find that most of my doctors are definitely practicing this kind of medicine now.

  2. Thanks Ellen for a reminder I needed. Last year my phycisian suggested some genetic screening because of the cancer history in my family and a close call I already had. I am following up and scheduling the screening!

    1. Great – Nancy! Being proactive about your health rather than re-active – is always best! I did the BRCA1 and BRCA2 screening as I am an Ashkenazi Jew. I did it for me….for my daughter and for my granddaughter!

  3. Knowledge is indeed power, and I love the way you empower so many women with informative posts such as these.

    I found this especially interesting: “Some suggest that we should leave DCIS alone, not call it a cancer, and instead consider it a “high-risk lesion.”” Perhaps Pollyanna-ish, but if I were to have cancer, I’d be far happier being able to call it a high-risk lesion. Very interesting and enlightening, Ellen.

  4. Knowledge is power for sure! When my hubby was diagnosed last year all I did was research and ask tons of questions. I had a hysterectomy after the birth of my second so I’ve been in menopause forever lol. Thanks for the info, very informative.

    1. Angela, thank you for your sweet words. I am very fortunate that so many doctors/scientists are passionate about helping the sisterhood lead healthy, happy lives. When I reach out to them to interview, I am always so delighted when they say,”yes”. These two doctors at the Yale Cancer Center were just wonderful.

  5. Thanks once again for this valuable information. There is so much to learn about ourselves that can affect our lives in ways we don’t even think about. Great info here! I hadn’t even thought about some of these things and how they interact with our bodies.

    1. Thanks, Wendy. Happy you found the post informative. I really enjoyed interviewing these two very bright doctors. They were so generous with their time and expertise.

  6. Hi Ellen:) this post really touches my heart in a personal way. At 73 my mom was diagnosed with breast cancer. You’ll probably need to sit down for the next thing im about to say. The oncologist told her to just move on. That she lived past her seventies and that was good enough. Needless to say, my mom&dad got the heck outa there. She went back to her gyno who had a few choice words for that oncologist… who doesn’t deserve dr in front of his name! My mom had a radical mastectomy and LIVED to tell the story:)! This happened in 1991. Today, there are so many more options! My awsome mama encouraged me to embrace Life! Don’t let anyone tell you cancer is a death sentence.

    1. Wow, Linda that is quite the story indeed. Thank goodness your Mom was her own health advocate and found the help that she needed and deserved! Thank you so much for sharing this story as it inspires all of us to listen to our body and take good care of ourselves.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Get The Latest Updates


No spam, notifications only about new products, updates.

Social Media


On Key

Related Posts

Birth Control and Menopause

If your cycle has been harder to keep up with than a spin class, you have intolerable menstrual cramps, or you are trying to prevent unwanted pregnancies… chances are you’re no stranger to birth control! For many women, birth control plays a leading role in their bodies’ performance– whether for pain or pleasure. So, what

My Recipe for the Best Thanksgiving Ever!

For this special edition of Menopause Mondays, let’s focus on how YOU can celebrate the day.  You may spend hours obsessing over the turkey today, but hey, let’s keep the cooking tips in the kitchen – stuffing a turkey with apples and oranges is great but definitely not a remedy for other kinds of moisture

family in kitchen cooking Thanksgiving dinner

Turning Hot Flashes into Thanksgiving Turkey Triumphs!

Welcome to another Menopause Mondays® , where we’re turning up the heat, quite literally, as we explore the unique connection between hot flashes and cooking Thanksgiving turkey. Today, we’re serving up three tips to help you master the art of managing hot flashes while keeping your turkey perfectly juicy this holiday season. Tip 1: The

Keeping Both Your Turkey and Vagina Moist This Holiday!

Welcome back to Menopause Mondays! With the holiday season here, I know you’re deep into Pinterest boards, Googling, and even calling Aunt Linda for those fail-proof tips to ensure that your Thanksgiving turkey isn’t dry. But while we’re on the topic of things that should remain moist, I’m here to chat about something else that

WordPress PopUp Plugin
Scroll to Top

If you want to educate your employees, colleagues, or friends about menopause, look no further!

Share via
Copy link